CASPA essay readers, please!

Questions about your physician assistant personal statement? Want some critique? This is the place.
Post Reply
IndyPAHopeful
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 7
Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2012 7:46 pm

CASPA essay readers, please!

Post by IndyPAHopeful » Wed Jun 13, 2012 2:22 pm

Okay fellow CASPA'ers, I've finally done my essay! I think (know!) I have work to do on it in order to make my experience and myself shine, but hopefully you can help me with that! Let me know what needs to be cut, changed... anything helps.

And for the record, this is all my own personal work, do your own, no plagiarizing! O0

Here it is, in all it's 4964 characters (with spaces!) of glory! Ahem...

_________________________________________________________________________________

It is not often that one can pinpoint the birth of a passion. Passions are deeply connected to an owner’s personal identity, rooted in a lifetime of experience and grow stronger over time; thus, pinpointing their origin can be difficult. But I know mine.

At a seminar in my late teens, I listened attentively as the man on stage detailed his life story to an audience of strangers. He spoke of a disease that had ravaged his life, killed countless friends, and finally claimed his lover as well. He spoke of being marginalized, even to this day, by a population afraid of his blood, and at times, by a medical community sworn to do him no harm. His disease still has no cure and, at the time he was diagnosed, lacked even a name: AIDS. I listened to his story and although I had come across the topic of HIV before, his story sparked something in me- in that moment, listening to that man speak, scientific interest melded with humanistic compassion, and my passion was born. I realized then that I very much wanted to be a part of the fight against HIV/AIDS by providing medical care to underserved populations.

In the years since I sat in that audience, that passion has not faded; my goal has remained at the forefront of my mind. I began exploring career options that would allow me to work clinically with HIV positive populations.

In the lab of Dr. Masliah I witnessed the terrible power of HIV on the human body. While there, I dissected brains of patients who had died of AIDS and were suspected to have HIV-related dementia. I also read morgue reports and clinical histories and witnessed autopsies first hand. At roughly the same time in my life, I also spent time in a neurology lab under Dr. Anita Bandrowski; both experiences gave me a greater understanding of neurology and how HIV acts pathologically in patients.

I joined Dr. Andy Yu’s lab shortly after I graduated. My work there had a clinical as well as an academic component- I worked with patients coinfected with both HIV and HCV on a clinical research study. I was responsible for a branch of the project that involved looking at varying doses of interferon as a way to control dual infections. I also looked for cellular markers in these patients that would give clues as to the immune status of the patients. I enjoyed the work because it was very translational- everything I was doing directly related to patient outcome and had the potential to expand our understanding of the best methods of treatment of this disease. It was while working here in this translational environment that I realized that while I enjoyed the research part of the job, what attracted me most was the patient care aspect. I realized that I wanted to be involved with treating patients on a day to day basis; that in order to fulfill my passion, my role in fighting this disease would be to care directly for the patients clinically, and after looking into different careers that would allow me to do this, my desire to become a Physician Assistant was born.

From my time in Dr. Yu’s lab, I moved on to working in a clinical pathology lab. I also began shadowing a PA in an after-hours primary care clinic dedicated to serving an inner city population. Both experiences have been both rewarding and eye-opening. In the clinical pathology lab, I have learned a great deal about disorders and diseases of the human body; in my shadowing experiences, I have learned even more about what it means to be a PA. Watching my PA mentor work and interact with patients has not only shown me the ins and outs of day to day PA life, it has given me a greater awareness of the wide range of problems faced by marginalized populations and the needs that exist in order to better serve these populations. For example, although my mentor works hard, at the end of the day, there are always more patients who need care and treatment, and it is clear to me that more PAs are needed to fill the gaps. I strongly feel that this is where I will fit in as a PA- as a primary care provider working with underserved populations.

I have gained experience in many different clinical settings, and have seen over and over how one disease, in particular, can ravage and destroy lives. I have seen the end results of a lifetime’s struggle with AIDS, looked inside the immune systems of patients co-infected with HIV and Hepatitis, shadowed in a clinic serving marginalized populations, and personally known and lost friends to the fight against AIDS. Each experience has contributed in a unique way to my passion, building it further and driving me towards the goals that took form that night in the audience. Thinking back to that day, listening to that man’s story, I know that the passion that was sparked in me then has been driving me all along to this ultimate goal, a career as a Physician Assistant. I would like the chance to fulfill my passion and begin this work, and I know that a highly exciting and fulfilling road lies before me.

PaulK
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 609
Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2011 12:24 pm

Re: CASPA essay readers, please!

Post by PaulK » Mon Jun 25, 2012 5:02 am

Indy, this reads very well. I really liked how you began with an important event - the speaker you heard - then went away to share with the reader about your experiences and how they helped your passion develop, and then closed by returning to the speaker. This is a very effective and time-honored format: grab attention, give information and develop, then return to the attention grabber and "weave" it in with the information you have shared.

I see no errors in the grammar or structure. Here and there is an occasional unnecessary word you might strike just to distill it a little. Unnecessary words dilute. Sometimes that's okay - I leave this up to you. Words I usually try to stamp out of my own writing are just, very, totally, completely, as well, even, still, I realize(d), very much, and also. You had a lot of "I realized." Also, I prefer things like "I explored" to "I began exploring." You get the picture. None of these make or break, and all are stylistic, so listen to your own drummer, man. 8)

Your essay does a nice job answering the questions they will have about you. My only other thoughts are three:

1) I might like to see a little more about what it is that makes PA fit your goal so much more than other medical fields. You alluded to this by talking about a PA's life and lifestyle. Could you maybe give one concrete example? I mean, why doesn't medical school or nursing school fill the bill for you?
2) You implied this, but I think I would use stronger words: that when you worked with a PA you actually saw a conduit or a direction by which you would accomplish the drive and interests you had that you developed when you heard the speaker. Maybe just plainly say, "While working directly with a PA I saw how I could bring my passion into reality." That reads a little cheesy, but you get my point. I can tell you were thinking it; saying it helps to put the puzzle piece firmly in place for the reader.
3) You clearly have a scientific ability - your research work shows that. Could you give some sort of *brief* anecdote that demonstrates how it is that you incorporate that personal aspect of medicine into your work? In other words, I understand that you are smart, sensitive, that you want to help others. Could you share something with me, the reader, that helps me to see that you are a great person to do those things? Something you helped a patient with that you not only could bring your dream alive, but that you would be great at it? If you wonder where you might get space to do this, I think you could summarize your research experience a little, as opposed to listing each doctor/lab you work in.

Just my thoughts.

This is a very nice essay! Keep in mind that no matter what anyone puts up, all I ever try to do is to tell them how they might make it EVEN BETTER. There is no perfection, only improvement. You know?

SUCCESS.

Paul

fjl001
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 7
Joined: Thu Jun 28, 2012 9:51 pm

Re: CASPA essay readers, please!

Post by fjl001 » Fri Jun 29, 2012 11:17 pm

I read your essay and am wondering if you already finalized it. It was very good; I can tell you have compassion and passion for the healthcare field. If you're still working on it, I thought I'd give my two cents. I agree with Paul's last tip; try to incorporate more of your distinct qualities into the essay. Your thesis seems to be about passion and how different things have contributed to this passion, but I would like to hear more about you as a person. (This is especially difficult to do for me because I tend to detail my work experience instead, but it makes a difference.) I know this is easier said than done, but here are some ideas:

- It sounds like you definitely were inspired for a long time and that led you to seek these research experiences, but what did you take away from them? Did they challenge any of your initial ideas about HIV or change your ideas towards becoming a PA?
- Maybe this is a no brainer, but what makes you want to serve under-privileged people specifically? What has contributed to this desire other than hearing the first account of the HIV patient?
- You suggest that you want to meet the need for PAs, maybe expand on this. Why is this morally significant to you? Maybe talk about the people you knew suffering from HIV because that focuses on your life specifically.
- How have your research experiences affected your goals to pursue PA wholeheartedly/specifically?
- Maybe elaborate on your desire to consider Internal Medicine - what is it that fits your style or goals?

IndyPAHopeful
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 7
Joined: Fri Jun 01, 2012 7:46 pm

Re: CASPA essay readers, please!

Post by IndyPAHopeful » Mon Jul 16, 2012 7:02 pm

thank you so much for both of your feedbacks! I am in the process of revising at the moment. My last reference just turned in their form so hoping to get this bad boy done pretty soon, but I will try to post a redraft before I turn it in! Your feedback is very useful to me and I greatly appreciate it!

Post Reply